By Alistair Talbert (ack: Liliana Schultz and Georgia Dodds-Wilts)
Thursday, 29 November, 2018
An employer was recently fined $45,000 following an incident in a confined space that left two employees hospitalised. Central Coast Metal Protectives Pty Ltd (CCMP) was convicted of breaching s 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) (WHS Act) after exposing two employees to a risk of death or serious injury. The penalty was initially set at $60,000 but was reduced by 25% to take into account CCMP’s early guilty plea.
Two CCMP employees were taken to hospital suffering the effects of fume inhalation associated with the lack of ventilation in the confined space where they worked. CCMP was engaged by KHR Services Pty Ltd (KHR) to assist with the restoration of a naval ship — specifically blasting and repainting a number of the ship’s pontoons.
On the day of the incident, the employees were instructed to clean the inside of a pontoon with paint thinners. The area inside the pontoon was about 12 cubic metres, roughly the same internal area as a large skip bin. The only access point was through an open hatch that measured 30 by 45 cm. The workers had no ventilation and were using faulty protective equipment. One employee used a paper face mask but this did not assist in respiratory protection.
The employees were found to be suffering the effects of being overcome with fumes, including vomiting and disorientation. They were taken to hospital and treated.
Failures by the employer
The Court found CCMP failed to meet the following duties under the WHS Act:
- the employees were not trained to work in confined space, or to handle fumes
- there was no ventilation in the confined space, despite ventilation equipment being present at the work site
- CCMP failed to follow the material safety data sheet (MSDS), which required personal protective equipment (PPE) to be worn and adequate ventilation equipment to be used. The MSDS required the employees to wear respirators and to not enter the confined space unless the ventilation was adequate
- CCMP failed to provide the two employees with functioning respiratory equipment
- the employees were unsupervised and there was no spotter watching them
- no risk assessment was undertaken or safe work method statement (SWMS) completed before commencing work
- no instruction was given to the employees on safe handling, use and storage of thinners
- the employees were not required to sign a confined space entry permit
- the confined space entry permit covering the task did not comply with the Regulations, and
- the air in the confined space was not tested for airborne contaminants at any time.
Judge Strathdee reduced the penalty for CCMP from $60,000 to $45,000 on account of CCMP’s guilty plea, noting that CCMP were remorseful, had been compliant and cooperative throughout the proceedings and pleaded guilty at the earliest opportunity. Interestingly, CCMP’s contributions to local social enterprises and charities were also cited as reasons for the penalty reduction.
Following the incident, CCMP took steps to prevent the harm reoccurring, including spending $20,000 on:
- discontinuing the use of thinners
- requiring confined space entry permits be signed regularly by employees
- providing all staff with relevant training
- implementing a supervision program when work in confined spaces was undertaken
- providing PPE, including air-fed respirators
- implementing air monitoring devices in confined spaces, and
- developing an updated SWMS.
Working in confined space creates a serious predisposition for health-related injuries. A lack of oxygen, coupled with airborne contaminants and flammable atmospheres, can pose significant risk to the health of workers. Accordingly, there are prescriptive regulations in all Australian states and territories regarding how to manage the risks to health and safety that arise from confined spaces.
Part 4.3 of the Work Health and Safety Regulations 2011 (Cth) outlines the requirements for specific control measures such as issuing confined space entry permits for the work, ensuring appropriate signage is displayed in relation to the work and a need for continuous communication with the worker from outside the space.
Under the harmonised WHS Act, multiple people hold health and safety duties in relation to confined spaces, including persons conducting business or undertaking (PCBU), designers, manufacturers and suppliers of plant or structures, officers and workers.
These duties include:
- managing health and safety risks associated with a confined space, including risks involved with entering, working in, on or near a confined space as well as the risk of inadvertent entry
- ensuring, so far as is reasonably practicable, that a worker doesn’t enter a confined space until all the duties imposed by legislation have been complied with in relation to that space, and
- establishing first aid and rescue procedures to be followed in the event of an emergency in the confined space.
Other confined space incidents
In 2018, Australia has seen multiple safety incidents involving confined spaces.
In January, two North Queensland men died after being overcome by fumes while cleaning the inside of a fibreglass tanker used to transport molasses.
In October, WorkSafe Victoria published news of the death of a 20-year-old apprentice who was overcome with fumes while working in a confined space at a business in Melbourne’s south. WorkSafe is currently investigating the incident, but it is believed the apprentice was working with power tools inside an open-ended tank.
How to prevent this occurring in your workplace
It is vital that PCBUs/employers are vigilant in assessing the risks, establishing necessary controls and remedying faults to protect the safety of employees and avoid prosecution. Employers may face significant penalties for failing to protect employees from the risks associated with working in confined spaces.
Steps toward compliance include:
- where possible, eliminating the need for people to enter a confined space
- training employees in how to work safely in confined spaces as well as handling and storing chemicals
- ensuring confined spaces have sufficient ventilation
- following the MSDS, including wearing PPE, providing adequate ventilation, wearing respirators and not allowing employees to enter confined spaces without adequate ventilation
- ensuring respirators provided are fully functional
- ensuring workers in confined spaces are spotted or supervised
- undertaking a risk assessment or SWMS before commencing work in a confined space
- requiring employees to sign a confined space permit each time they enter or leave the confined space
- testing and monitoring the oxygen in the confined space for airborne contaminants, and
- conducting regular checks of safety systems in relation to confined spaces to make sure all employees are abiding by the protocols in place and that all equipment is functional.
This case reminds employers that failing to comply with the WHS Act and corresponding Regulations can bring dire consequences — not only for the business, but for the health and safety of employees.
Employers are urged to familiarise themselves with the legislation in their jurisdiction, as well as the SafeWork (or equivalent, depending on your state or territory) Code of Practice regarding confined spaces.
Safe Work Australia has released advice for persons conducting a business or undertaking to...
National Safety’s Editor, Dr JOSEPH BRENNAN, speaks with an air quality expert, a...
Lawyers JACKSON INGLIS and ERIC HALDEN explore the difference under the law between disobedient...