Ghost qualifications: the high cost of card counting in construction

Construction is battling an influx of what can only be termed ‘ghost qualifications’; credentials that appear perfectly authentic, but are actually entirely void, out-of-date or legally non-compliant. A situation that, as BRENDAN TORAZZI — CEO of RTO provider AlertForce — explains, is all thanks to a simple-but-little-known rule.

Construction sites across Australia are riding the wave of an infrastructure boom and workers who saw jobs dry up in 2024 are returning to sites, excited to be able to wave their white card at the gate.

For lead contractors and safety professionals, relying on simple ‘card counting’ at the site gate is turning a simple administrative task into a minefield of potential health and safety litigation and negligence claims.

The delayed impact of insolvencies

To understand how ghost qualifications have become such a concern, we need to look at the macroeconomics of Australian construction over the last 24 months.

Data from the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) paints a bruising picture of the 2024–25 financial period. Hit by a toxic combination of legacy fixed-price contracts, severe supply chain spikes and escalating material costs, nearly 3000 construction firms collapsed into administration in a single year.

Tens of thousands of workers were impacted. When a construction firm collapses, its workforce does not simply vanish. Instead, thousands of subcontractors, carpenters, labourers and plant operators disperse rapidly. Many ended up having to take their transferable skills into other sectors, migrating into booming parallel fields like transport, automated logistics or hospitality.

Now, however, with industry activity surging again, many of these workers are returning to commercial and civil sites. The problem is, the safety qualifications they have cards for, may not actually be valid. Many are returning with a paper trail that has silently expired while they were gone.

The inactivity void

Something that many people seem to be unaware of is that under the national Work Health and Safety (WHS) Regulations, a white card (or its historical regional equivalents) is not a lifetime licence.

The regulations state that if a worker has not performed any construction work for a continuous period of two consecutive years, the card ceases to be valid. The worker is legally required to retake the general induction training.

Consider the thousands of labourers who transitioned into warehousing or delivery driving during the peak of the 2024 building downturn. As they return to high-risk environments, they present a physical white card issued years prior. On its face, the card displays a valid number and name. In the eyes of the law, however, the card is dead.

This inactivity void means that a site manager who waves that worker through the gate is deploying an un-inducted person into a high-risk zone.

Legacy training and cancelled RTOs

A clamp down on low-quality training and a drive to standardise qualifications are more-obvious-but-also-often-missed risks to compliance.

Workers still holding historical blue cards or certification from low-quality training providers are also a risk to safety compliance. While the current national unit ‘CPCWHS1001 Prepare to work safely in the construction industry’ is the benchmark,¹ thousands of older workers still carry out-of-date regional cards or credentials minted by Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) that have since been shut down.

In recent years, the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) has aggressively weeded out RTOs operating as ‘card factories’ over concerns that these providers issued white cards via rapid online courses without robust identity verification or authentic assessment. If an incident occurs and the subsequent regulatory investigation traces a worker’s qualification back to a deregistered, non-compliant RTO, the head contractor’s safety management system will be heavily scrutinised.

The ultimate test of any qualification is whether the knowledge translates to behaviour. Safe Work Australia data highlights the ongoing, sobering reality of workplace danger and construction remains one of the deadliest fields, consistently logging dozens of lives lost annually, alongside more than 17,000 serious workers compensation claims per year.

A card proves a fee was paid and a test was clicked; it does not prove the worker understands dynamic risk management on a live site. The standardisation of training and qualifications is there to provide assurance to all parties that a card holder understands how to maintain the right safety standards.

Insurance risks and industrial manslaughter

Why should a commercial project manager or HR director care about a lapsed two-year rule if the worker ‘knows what they are doing’? The answer lies in the evolving, high-stakes legal framework governing Australian workplaces.

With industrial manslaughter laws active across almost all states and territories, the threshold for criminal negligence has never been lower for corporate officers. If a supervisor or director fails to maintain an airtight verification system and a fatal accident occurs involving an unqualified or out-of-date worker, the defence of “we checked his card” will be worth as much as the piece of plastic the card is printed on. It won’t stand up in court and it could invalidate your insurance.

Regulators do not look at a physical card as a shield. They look at it as an entry point. If a worker’s general induction is found to be legally void due to the two-year inactivity rule, the business can be found to have breached its primary duty under Section 19 of the WHS Act — failing to provide the necessary information, training and instruction to ensure safety.

The insurance implications are also pretty severe. Most commercial general liability and workers compensation policies contain strict exclusions regarding unlicenced or uninducted personnel. Discovering a ghost qualification after a major structural failure or injury can result in an insurer walking away from a multi-million-dollar claim, leaving directors personally exposed to catastrophic financial damages.

**************************************************

5 ways to mitigate risk

There are some simple measures that can be put in place to keep on top of ghost qualifications and ensure that anyone contracted to work on site have the right level of compliance.

1. Prioritise verification

Contractors and construction companies must completely dismantle the traditional gate-check mentality. Instead, moving to an active verification-first framework. Site managers and HR professionals should implement a systematic protocol to filter out ghost qualifications before a boot ever touches the site.

2. Conduct mandatory audits for inactivity

Do not just photocopy a white card during onboarding. Update your digital enrolment forms to include a mandatory, signed declaration from the worker stating the date and location of their last active construction role. If a prospective hire has not been in a qualifying role for at least 24 months, make sure they are signed up to undertake the required training before they start. Most reputable training providers will offer a number of opportunities a month to complete training on the most needed courses.

3. Mandate red-flag filters for older units

Ensure your digital vendor management systems and site gatekeepers explicitly look for the current national unit CPCWHS1001. Older or state-specific legacy credentials should be treated as high-risk anomalies. If a worker presents a card older than five to 10 years, even if they claim continuous employment, prioritise them for an updated training assessment.

4. Audit the issuing RTO against ASQA Registers

Ensure your compliance team cross references the RTO code printed on the worker’s card against the current training.gov.au database. If the issuing provider was closed due to regulatory sanctions or non-compliance, the credential must be flagged for internal review.

5. Invest in robust site re-inductions and practical gateways

Never treat a site induction as a quick box-ticking exercise or a video a worker watches on their phone for 10 minutes before turning up for work. Use your site re-inductions to conduct brief, practical verbal competency checks.

Ask targeted questions about common risk scenarios on topics such as exclusion zones, scaffolding tags and line-of-sight principles for heavy plant machinery. If a worker holds a card but struggles with basic spatial hazard identification, keep them off the site until they complete an official training session — many can be done via online webinars. It is a worthwhile investment in half a day of their time, and yours.

**************************************************

Putting safety over paper compliance

Meeting demand for staffing during a construction boom demands speed, but that cannot be as a result of shortcuts. As thousands of workers shift back into high-intensity environments after a bruising couple of years of industry disruption, the risk of the ghost qualification will continue to escalate.

A business that relies solely on physical card counting is building its safety culture on quicksand. By stepping up to an assertive, verification-first model, lead contractors do more than just protect themselves from regulatory prosecutions and ruined insurance policies, they ensure that when a worker steps onto a site, they possess the genuine, active competency required to go home safely at the end of the day.

Brendan Torazzi. Source: Supplied

^{1. CPCWHS1001 Prepare to work safely in the construction industry. Training.gov.au. Accessed June 22, 2026. https://training.gov.au/training/details/CPCWHS1001/unitdetails}

Top image credit: iStock.com/Jacob Wackerhausen. Stock image used is for illustrative purposes only.